The Shift in Shubman Gill's Batting Position: Insights from Rohit Sharma

Gain insights into the shift in Shubman Gill's batting position from the perspective of Rohit Sharma. Explore the reasons behind this change and its impact on Gill's performance in the cricketing world.

By Crickified Mohit
New Update

Rohit Sharma and Shubman Gill during a practice session ahead of South Africa vs India 1st Test at SuperSport Park, Centurion (Image Source: PTI)

In the world of cricket, strategies and lineups are constantly evolving. One such change was witnessed during the India vs. South Africa Test series when the Indian team management decided to demote Shubman Gill from his opening spot to batting at No. 3. Rohit Sharma, the captain, shed light on the dynamics behind this decision and revealed his personal dislike for batting at No. 3. In this article, we will delve into the reasons behind the shift in Gill's position and explore Rohit Sharma's perspective on batting order preferences.


The Experimentation: Gill at No. 3

The Indian team management brought in Yashasvi Jaiswal to open the innings alongside Rohit Sharma, demoting Shubman Gill to the crucial No. 3 position. This move was aimed at rejuvenating the batting lineup, moving beyond the established players like Cheteshwar Pujara and Ajinkya Rahane. Gill's promotion to No. 3, with Shreyas Iyer at No. 4, indicated a fresh guard for the Indian team.

However, the success of this experimentation could only be evaluated after a longer run. The first Test at Centurion provided a glimpse of Gill's performance at his new position. In the first innings, he was dismissed for 2, and although he looked solid during his knock of 26 in the second innings, he eventually fell to Marco Jansen's bowling.


"There is not much difference (on opening to batting at number 3). It takes just 1 ball for a number 3 to go in. And sometimes when an opener gets injured, a number 3 has to walk out and open the innings. I don't see much difference there. Gill is smart and understands his batting pretty well," Rohit Sharma told the reporters ahead of the second Test starting on Wednesday at Newlands, Cape Town

Gill's Test Career and the Impetus for Change

Shubman Gill, known for his impressive performances in ODIs, had not quite left a significant impact as a Test opener. Apart from his remarkable 91 at the Gabba against Australia and a maiden century during the Border-Gavaskar Trophy, his contributions have been limited. With a record of 966 runs from 33 innings, the team management believed that moving Gill down the order might be a strategic decision, considering his age and potential for growth as a professional cricketer.


Gill's Preference for No. 3

The decision to bat at No. 3 was not imposed on Shubman Gill; it was his own choice. Rohit Sharma highlighted that Gill had expressed his preference for this position. Gill's experience in the Ranji Trophy and his familiarity with batting around that position influenced his decision. Although he has opened in both Test and limited-overs formats, Gill believes that No. 3 is where he can excel and contribute significantly to the team's success.

"He prefers that number. He has batted in the Ranji Trophy at that number around that position. He has opened in Test and limited overs games but the number 3 was his preference. He feels he can do well for us batting at that position. It is an individual thing about how you think about certain positions," Rohit said


Also Read Akash Chopra on Shubman's 'unusual' no.3 request

Rohit Sharma's Insights on Batting Positions


Rohit Sharma, who has batted at various positions throughout his Test career, expressed his dislike for any position other than opening. With an impressive record of 2097 runs in 43 innings as an opener, Rohit's average of 51.15 demonstrates his proficiency in this position. However, his average drops to 1585 when batting between No. 3 and 6, with three centuries and six fifties. Interestingly, Rohit's best average of 54.58 comes when he bats at No. 6, but his fondness for opening remains undeniable.

The Discomfort of Batting at No. 3

Rohit Sharma candidly admitted his disdain for batting at No. 3. He firmly believes that a batsman should either open the innings or wait for an opportunity to bat at No. 5 or 6. Since embracing the role of an opener, Rohit has found his true calling, and he feels that positions from No. 3 to 7 are not ideal for any batsman. This insight provides a glimpse into the mindset and preferences of a seasoned cricketer.


"I hated batting at number 3 and that is my opinion. Either you open the batting or you wait a little to go down the order to bat at number 5 or 6. Since I started opening, from 3 onwards till number 7, I don't think it is the right position for anyone," pointed out Rohit

The Significance of Batting Order

The batting order in cricket plays a crucial role in determining the outcome of a match. Each position requires specific skills, temperament, and adaptability. Openers set the tone for the innings, while the middle order stabilizes and consolidates. The No. 3 position demands a combination of both aggression and resilience. Understanding the nuances of each position enables players to make informed decisions about their preferred role in the team.


The Evolution of Batting Strategies

Over the years, batting strategies have evolved, and teams have experimented with different lineups to maximize their chances of success. The advent of limited-overs cricket has led to the blurring of traditional batting roles. Players like Rohit Sharma have successfully transitioned from the middle order to the top of the batting lineup, bringing a new dimension to the game.

The Individuality of Batting Preferences

Each player has unique strengths and preferences when it comes to batting positions. Some thrive as openers, while others excel in the middle order. The key is to understand individual strengths and align them with the team's requirements. Shubman Gill's preference for No. 3 and Rohit Sharma's affinity for opening are prime examples of how players carve their niche within the team.

Team Dynamics and Flexibility

Team management plays a vital role in ensuring the success of batting order changes. The ability to adapt and be flexible with the lineup based on conditions, opposition, and player form is crucial. The Indian team's decision to experiment with Shubman Gill's batting position is a testament to their commitment to finding the right balance and nurturing young talent.


The shift in Shubman Gill's batting position from opener to No. 3 in Test cricket was a strategic move by the Indian team management. Gill's preference for this position, coupled with Rohit Sharma's insights on batting order, sheds light on the dynamics within the team. As cricket evolves, so do batting strategies, and it is essential to adapt and experiment to find the perfect balance. The success of this shift can only be determined with time, but it showcases the team's commitment to nurturing young talent and exploring new avenues for success.

Latest Stories