The Selection Conundrum in Indian Cricket: Jadeja Fumes Over Unfair Ishan Kishan's Treatment

The selection process in Indian cricket has sparked controversy as Ajay Jadeja expresses displeasure over what he sees as unfair treatment towards Ishan Kishan. Find out more about this conundrum and its impact on Indian cricket.

By Crickified Mohit
New Update

Ishan Kishan during India vs Australia 1st T20I Match at Dr. Y.S. Rajasekhara Reddy ACA-VDCA Cricket Stadium, Visakhapatnam

Indian cricket has always been a hotbed of talent, producing some of the world's greatest players. However, there have been instances where promising players have been overlooked or prematurely discarded. The recent controversy surrounding the treatment of Ishan Kishan during the T20I series between India and Australia has once again brought the issue of player selection to the forefront. Former cricketer Ajay Jadeja has expressed his frustration over Kishan's exclusion from the playing XI, raising questions about the overall selection process in Indian cricket. In this article, we delve into the details of Kishan's treatment and explore the broader problem of player selection in Indian cricket.


The Background Story

The T20I series between India and Australia saw a second-string Indian side led by Suryakumar Yadav, as several key players were either rested or unavailable due to various reasons. Ishan Kishan, a promising young talent, featured in the first three matches of the series, showcasing his potential with impressive performances. However, to the surprise of many, he was released from the playing XI after the third encounter, raising eyebrows and prompting criticism from Jadeja and others.

Ajay Jadeja's Criticism


Ajay Jadeja voiced his concerns over Kishan's treatment, questioning the decision to exclude him from the remaining matches of the series. He expressed disbelief that Kishan would be fatigued after just three matches and argued that the young batter deserved a spot in the playing XI for the World Cup matches. Jadeja emphasized Kishan's ability to change the game with his explosive batting and urged the selectors to provide him with consistent opportunities rather than treating him as a trial player.

"There was a series right after the World Cup. Ishan Kishan played three matches and went home. Was he really that tired after three matches that he needed rest? He didn't even play a lot of games at the World Cup. He deserved his spot in the playing XI for the first few World Cup matches. How many Indian players have scored a double century on a good day? He can change the game on his day. When will he get ready? Will you keep him in on trial all the time? In the last two years, how many games has he played? This problem of Indian cricket is not of today, it is very old that we don’t select (players) but reject them," Jadeja told Sports Tak

Kishan's Performance


Ishan Kishan's performance in the T20I series against Australia showcased his talent and potential as a game-changer. While he recorded a five-ball duck in the third match, he started the series with an impressive knock of 58 off 39 balls in Visakhapatnam. He followed it up with another brilliant innings, scoring 52 off 32 balls in Thiruvananthapuram. Kishan's average of 36.67 and a total of 110 runs in three innings against a strong Australian side further highlighted his capabilities.

"Ishan Kishan didn't even play the entire five-match T20I series against Australia. He was sent home after three matches to rest. So, if this is going to continue, how will you ensure that he is fully ready?," Jadeja added

The Larger Issue


The controversy surrounding Kishan's treatment is not an isolated incident but rather a symptom of a long-standing problem in Indian cricket. Jadeja's comment, "We don't select players but reject them," reflects the frustration felt by many players who have been overlooked or discarded without adequate opportunities. This issue of player selection and management has plagued Indian cricket for years, hindering the growth and development of promising talents.

Lack of Consistency

One of the primary concerns in the selection process is the lack of consistency. Players are often given limited chances to prove themselves, and even a few failures can result in their exclusion from the team. This approach not only hampers the confidence of young players but also deprives the team of potential match-winners. The case of Ishan Kishan highlights the need for a more patient and nurturing approach towards talent.


High Competition and Pressure

The intense competition and pressure in Indian cricket make it even more challenging for young players to establish themselves. With a vast pool of talented cricketers vying for limited spots in the national team, the pressure to perform consistently is immense. This cut-throat competition often leads to players being dropped without sufficient opportunities to prove their worth, as witnessed in Kishan's case.

The Role of Selectors and Coaches


The selection committee and coaches play a crucial role in shaping the composition of the team. Their decisions can have a significant impact on the careers of players. It is essential for selectors to identify and nurture talent, providing them with adequate opportunities to grow and develop. Coaches, on the other hand, need to create a supportive and encouraging environment that allows players to express themselves freely.

The Way Forward

To address the selection conundrum in Indian cricket, several key steps need to be taken. First and foremost, there should be a consistent and transparent selection process, where players are given fair chances based on their performances. A balance needs to be struck between the need for immediate results and the nurturing of long-term talent.


Emphasizing Player Development

Player development should be a priority, and young talents like Ishan Kishan should be given sufficient exposure at the international level. The focus should shift from short-term gains to long-term investments in talented players. This approach requires a shift in mindset, where selectors and team management prioritize the growth and development of players over immediate results.


The controversy surrounding Ishan Kishan's treatment in the T20I series against Australia has once again highlighted the selection conundrum in Indian cricket. The issue of players being rejected rather than selected is a long-standing problem that requires immediate attention. By adopting a more consistent and nurturing approach towards talent, Indian cricket can ensure the growth and success of its players in the long run. It is time to address this issue and create an environment where players are selected based on their potential and given adequate opportunities to prove themselves on the field.

Latest Stories