India vs South Africa: ICC Rates Newlands Pitch as 'Unsatisfactory'

The Newlands pitch used for the India vs South Africa cricket match has been deemed 'unsatisfactory' by the International Cricket Council (ICC). Get all the details and analysis of this crucial match here.

New Update
India vs South Africa Newlands Pitch

India vs South Africa 2024, 2nd Test Match

n a highly anticipated second Test match between South Africa and India, the International Cricket Council (ICC) has rated the pitch at Newlands in Cape Town as 'unsatisfactory'. The thrilling two-day contest saw India emerge victorious by seven wickets. The pitch's treacherous nature, characterized by quick and unpredictable bounce, made batting exceedingly challenging for both teams. This assessment by the ICC has raised concerns about the quality of the playing surface and its impact on the game. Cricket South Africa has the option to appeal the decision within 14 days.


The Newlands Pitch Analysis

A Difficult Battleground

The Newlands pitch presented an arduous test for the batsmen, with the ball bouncing alarmingly throughout the match. Stuart Broad, the ICC match referee, expressed his reservations, stating, "The pitch in Newlands was very difficult to bat on. The ball bounced quickly and sometimes alarmingly throughout the match, making it difficult to play shots."


Impact on the Match

The extreme bounce led to numerous batsmen being struck on the gloves and resulted in wickets falling due to the awkwardness of the delivery. South Africa, after winning the toss and electing to bat, suffered a catastrophic collapse, being bowled out for a mere 55 runs in the first session of play. India initially seemed to have the upper hand, reaching 153/4 with notable contributions from Rohit Sharma, Shubman Gill, and Virat Kohli. However, they too succumbed to the challenging conditions, losing six wickets for the exact same total.

Aiden Markram's Resilient Century


On the first day, the Proteas faced an uphill battle as they walked out to bat again, trailing India by 98 runs. Aiden Markram displayed resilience amidst the chaos, scoring a century that offered some semblance of hope for the hosts. Despite his efforts, the South African team struggled and was eventually bundled out for 176, leaving India with a target of 79 runs for victory.

India's Successful Run Chase

Yashasvi Jaiswal provided India with a confident start in the run chase, scoring 28 runs off just 23 deliveries, including six boundaries. Although Shubman Gill and Virat Kohli fell quickly, it was Shreyas Iyer who sealed the victory with a boundary, with skipper Rohit Sharma at the other end. India's triumph in the match resulted in a 1-1 series draw, with both teams showcasing their mettle on the challenging Newlands pitch.


ICC Sanctions and Appeal Process

Demerit Points and Suspensions

As a consequence of the pitch being deemed unsatisfactory, the Newlands pitch received one demerit point from the ICC. When a venue accumulates six demerit points, it faces a suspension from hosting any international cricket for 12 months. If the number of demerit points reaches 12, the suspension is extended to 24 months. It is crucial for Cricket South Africa to evaluate their options carefully in light of the potential consequences.


Appeal Possibilities

Cricket South Africa has a 14-day window to lodge an appeal against the ICC's sanction. This presents an opportunity for them to contest the evaluation of the pitch and provide their perspective on the conditions faced by the players. The outcome of the appeal process will determine the final verdict on the Newlands pitch and whether any further action needs to be taken.


The ICC's rating of the Newlands pitch as 'unsatisfactory' has brought attention to the challenges faced by both teams during the second Test between South Africa and India. The treacherous bounce made batting extremely difficult and resulted in a swift conclusion to the match. While India emerged victorious, the quality of the playing surface has raised concerns within the cricketing community. The appeal process provides Cricket South Africa with an opportunity to present their case and potentially contest the ICC's assessment. As the series progresses, both teams will be eager to showcase their skills on pitches that provide a fair and balanced contest between bat and ball.

Latest Stories